PY Online Forums - Bringing the Pontiac Hobby Together

PY Online Forums - Bringing the Pontiac Hobby Together (https://forums.maxperformanceinc.com/forums/index.php)
-   Pontiac - Street (https://forums.maxperformanceinc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=418)
-   -   Thoughts on knocking sound?? (https://forums.maxperformanceinc.com/forums/showthread.php?t=862684)

slowbird 11-05-2022 04:38 PM

Thoughts on knocking sound??
 
https://youtu.be/yWdNc6KGFZo

Well we have nice knocking type sound in our GP. It has about 300miles on it and 5 1/8 mile runs. Not sure when the knock developed but it was there before the racing occurred. I haven't had time to really look into it much but it's loudest on the driverside towards rear. Oil in top of head is clean, oil pressure is good, it doesn't seem to change from cold to warmed up.
My action plan when i get to car next weekend is change oil and cut filter, disconnect converter from flex plate, pull drive belts (so engine is isolated from everything). But I think it's coming from down inside :(.
Any thoughts?

mgarblik 11-05-2022 05:15 PM

I like the plan of an oil change and filter inside inspection. Before you isolate the engine from everything else, a quick check is to set the idle at about 1000 RPM. Use insulated pliers and pull up one plug wire at a time to disable it. Then move to the next one. If the noise goes away with wire out and comes back with it operating, you found the cylinder. If the noise stays, it's main bearings, or something outside the engine. (flex plate, accessories, torque converter).

johnta1 11-05-2022 05:18 PM

1st thing I'd do is take valve cover off to see if everything looks OK.
Check that header gasket isn't blown out.


Then yank engine.


:(

slowbird 11-05-2022 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnta1 (Post 6384868)
1st thing I'd do is take valve cover off to see if everything looks OK.
Check that header gasket isn't blown out.


Then yank engine.


:(

Had valve cover off and things looked good, ran my finger through what oil was sitting there and oil there looked clean, rockers looked/felt normal.

turbo69bird 11-05-2022 06:40 PM

Are the lush rods turning? Someone on here was having an issue w that on a new build sounds like your is fairly fresh. Is it hydraulic or solid lifter? Could be a wrist pin too. Doesn’t sound like a rod knock at all.

slowbird 11-05-2022 06:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by turbo69bird (Post 6384891)
Are the lush rods turning? Someone on here was having an issue w that on a new build sounds like your is fairly fresh. Is it hydraulic or solid lifter? Could be a wrist pin too. Doesn’t sound like a rod knock at all.

Hyd roller. Rockers and pushrods seemed to adjusted and good. But I do plan to look them over better next weekend. I had about 15min to look things over now. So didn't get too far.

Murf 11-05-2022 07:46 PM

Maybe a rocker hitting the bolt hole area on those M/T’s ?
I ‘ve had that happen before. It would be nice if it was that easy.
Take a pair of stock valve covers & try em.

Good luck!
Murf

Tom Vaught 11-05-2022 07:50 PM

I had to run a double cork gasket with some versions of the M/T Valve Covers to
have proper rocker arm clearance.

Tom V.

AG 11-05-2022 10:37 PM

Make sure crank pulley isn't loose.

chuckies76ta 11-06-2022 05:19 AM

Dam that's too bad. Does sound like it's coming from internals to me. Ya run it without the torque converter connected first and like AG says check the balancer and crank pulley.

25stevem 11-06-2022 07:12 AM

After you kill each cylinder with the yanking the plug deal if that proves fruitless, and if the cars auto trans then unbolt the converter and back it off the flexplate and see if that changes things.

Half-Inch Stud 11-06-2022 09:46 AM

An SD Rod can knock a dented oil pan, OR when sitting on an F-body crossmember.

Check crank pulley for ovel holes allowing slosh-knock. Itsa thing.

In your case the Roller Rocker Arm(s) is knocking the M/T cover bolt boss or ceiling. Pull em, inspect em, grind em, and use even thicker gaskets.

Sirrotica 11-06-2022 01:29 PM

FWIW, I've run into that same type noise that sounds like valve train mis-adjustment that is actually loose valve guides. The valve being able to rock in the guide will sound like your noise does. I've found if you run the engine at idle and exert pressure on the spring retainer pushing it to the side the noise changes, and you can isolate which one/ones are making the noise.

I've also used a piece of vacuum hose running to my ear to isolate engine noises as to where they originate from. Of course the long screwdriver, or long socket extension can also be used, but I prefer the hose method to zero in on the origination of the noise.

Back in 77 when GM decided tp listen to bean counters, instead of the people that knew better, and made the iron alloy in the heads and blocks softer (less nickel) than it was previously, valve guides went out in GM cars quite often, especially SBCs. The first example I ran into was a 1977 Impala 305 with only 17,000 miles that had loose valve guides. GM continued to make the low nickel parts, losing them a huge market share to other manufacturers because of engine failures at low mileage due to soft cast iron alloy.

I also noticed from the video, that there seems to be a slight miss that coincides with the noise. Maybe hook a tach up, and see how much each cylinder drops when pulling plug wires. Loose guide could possibly cause one cylinder to be slightly weak due to the valve seating poorly.

Dragncar 11-07-2022 12:38 AM

Check your valve lash very carefully.

NeighborsComplaint 11-07-2022 01:47 AM

How’s your rocker arm to retainer clearance?

slowbird 11-07-2022 08:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragncar (Post 6385182)
Check your valve lash very carefully.

They're hyd, not much to check.

slowbird 11-07-2022 08:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NeighborsComplaint (Post 6385184)
How’s your rocker arm to retainer clearance?

That's good, that was looked at when assembled

Half-Inch Stud 11-07-2022 09:59 AM

Check the Rocker Arm to Valve Cover clearance, like that guy in Post 12 said.

slowbird 11-07-2022 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Half-Inch Stud (Post 6385214)
Check the Rocker Arm to Valve Cover clearance, like that guy in Post 12 said.

I saw no witness marks on rockers or cover. But I do plan to start it up without cover to check things.

Murf 11-07-2022 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by slowbird (Post 6385231)
I saw no witness marks on rockers or cover. But I do plan to start it up without cover to check things.

On those M/T’s look for contact between the edges of the rockers and the bolt hole area at the top of the covers. Would be great if it’s that simple!

Good luck
Murf


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:39 PM.