Sweet, I have been reading this thread and feeling bad for you. Then I went to the readers rides section and read the text and saw the pictures of your Judge (Judge wanna-be?).
Now listen carefully to what I have to say........... SHUT THE HELL UP!!!!! Damn man, you have a BEAUTIFUL car, and if it is not a Judge, so be it! I have $15K into a damn 74 A-body car and I'm still not done AND it will never be as desirable as your Judge. If I were you, I would be ticked off that the car was misrepresented, but you were not financially screwed in this deal. Had you paid $20K-$30K, then yes, I'd be getting a lawyer. Also, you are getting such second hand information from an unreliable source, why would you put any stock into what you are told by that looser?
Get the PHS documentation directly from PHS, and see what it says. If it is not a real Judge, enjoy the car and don't represent it as anything but a clone. If it is a real Judge, bask in the glory of your find.
Relax and enjoy your car my friend. The other party in this saga is probably royally p1ssed to see that you scored such a "sweet Judge"