[Greg Reid]

Ugh is right. VERY sorry you had this trouble based on my recommendations.
I don't think you're going to get any better results with another product just because it's made for automotive apps as opposed to household purposes. Also, I've used the Bare Metal foil on some apps like model airplanes and such and the Spaz Stix looks more like chrome than any kind of foil in my humble opinion...by FAR.
I have used the Krylon 'Rust Tough' on MANY, MANY things under the hood of my car and on the dash as described in this thread. Never had anything but great results. It is my favorite rattle can paint.
I really think your dash is contaminated with something to get those 'fish-eyes' but I'm no expert. Just a guy that has had this happen to me from time to time.
Sometimes I've been able to able to get it cleaned up and others, not. Maybe something strong like HOT water and dishwashing or laundry detergent? Maybe even toss the thing in the dishwasher.
EDIT- On second look, I see that it 'fish-eyed' even on the tape. Looks like you got a defective product to me. I've never had any problems with that paint.