This thread has been a fun debate.
I have always liked the 68's. For me I like how they hold some of the earlier 60's class with the vent windows, ignition switch in the dash, etc, but without the big body of earlier years. So to me its funny to hear those features picked on because those are the cues I really like about them. Both years are so similar, & I love both years. It's interesting that there is such a divided opinion. Both 68 & 69 are really great cars. But its still fun to listen, argue & debate the details.